Webcomic Book Club Full Reviews
of Dinosaur Comics by Ryan North


Hey, wouldn't it be cool if we made a comic online....about dinosaurs? And they only did one thing all the time! Wouldn't it be cool?

Take that late night, sleep-deprived dorm concept, make it real, and make it work. You have "Dinosaur Comics."

Art:Not applicable. There's some nice guest art, but part of the point of this is how the art's the same. And after reading through the archives, I think I'd be kind of unhappy if the art started to vary. That's a hard thing to do.

Story: Somewhat loose. There are story arcs, but they're usually there to keep a joke going more than anything else. "Dinosaur Comics" usually keeps things in some chronological order-such as Tyrannosaurus and Utahraptor's gay love affair (how? We don't know!)-but it doesn't really keep track. It doesn't even try.

Characters: Surprisingly developed. Tyrannosaurus acts as a sort of "misconception soundboard," as he continually uses half-understood philosophical standpoints as a justification for his passion-stomping things. But Utahraptor must tear his assumptions down for the good of all. And stuff. Utahraptor isn't really a skeptic, he just feels compelled to correct Tyrannosaurus when he's wrong. So he's helpful, but also rather intrusive.

Writing: The be all and the end all for most clip-art comics, and "Dinosaur Comics" has it in spades. The very fact that dinosaurs will argue about the technical definition of nihilism reaches back to Monty Python. And in the same way, I don't know how to really explain why "Dinosaur Comics" is so funny. But it is.

Overall: The one issue with "Dinosaur Comics" is that it's not immediately accessible. If you like the format and understand the humor, it's a winner. If not, then I don't know how someone could explain it. Regardless, it gets 9 out of 10.
Review by Benor Fri Dec 31 2004 03:24 PM

Ah, another one of those "I don't give a damn about art" comics.

Dinosaur comics is one that carries a unique concept: Every comic has the exact same panel layout, with the characters in the exact same positions all the time, with slight variations avery once in a while. The only thing different between comics is the dialogue.

There are three characters: T-Rex, Dromiceiomimus and Utahraptor. T-Rex likes to stomp on things, and he often tries to put some kind of witty or philisophical spin on his activities, making him think he's all that. Dromiceiomimus is just a bystander, sometimes offering helpful (but universally ignored) advice to T-Rex. Utahraptor is the counterbalance to T-Rex's rash, self-involved behavior, but he more often comes off as a spoilsport. After Utahrapter gives T-Rex the heads-up, T-Rex has one panel to make his retort, in which he usually is reduced to swearing and using petty insults.

One may think this process is formulaic, but the beauty of it all is that we know that. The author isn't trying to hide anything here. We know how the panels will play out. What's funny is the amount of creative ways the author uses these six panels in order to bring us different variations on the same thing happening over and over again. Does the girl get stomped on or not? Where is Utahraptor in panel 6? What is Dromiceiomimus' role in all of this? Sometimes different visual effects are used to alter the images, but the layout remains the same, except the time when Utahraptor travels to an alternate universe and all the panels are backward.

Of course, all this can be tiring if you read so many in a row, as the repeating images and can make the eyes start to wander. The funniest comics for me later on were the ones that took advantage of the formula to bring a new, refreshing adaptation of the six-panel layout, as they simply caught me off-guard. These happen at just the right pace so once I start getting tired of seeing the same old thing I get a little breather.

This comic is simply amusing, and it's a novel idea to be sure. It's made all the better that the dialogue can remain somewhat fresh and original throughout the whole thing, with some variations in the layout and presentation thrown in every once and a while to keep things from getting stagnant. This is also somethig that the audience can very easily participate in, as many people have made their own interpretations on the six-panel layout themselves in the fan-art section. Nice.
Review by Cobra Thu Dec 30 2004 07:15 AM

This is a fellow who has successfully written a webcomic for what is nearing a year without ever changing the panels involved, and yet the man still produces comedy. No, there is no character development. That's okay.

If /anyone/ treats this with the least bit of intellectual foppery, Thal gets to stabbing, okay?
Review by Thalamasa Tue Dec 28 2004 01:05 PM

Offsite Review Summaries

"Each weekday a new comic is posted; each weekday the comic uses the exact same artwork as every dinosaur comic before it. The same picture template is used, with only the dialogue changed. This has almost been done unintentionally by other cartoonists who like to copy and paste or cannot draw, and intentionally by many of his fans, who often take it far beyond his own experiments." more...
Read Full Review by Wikipedia contributors at Wikipedia Fri Mar 12 2004

Visitor Reviews & Comments

Rules so many schools!
Review by Dr. Rules Sat Jul 16 2005 11:23 AM

Summary Reviews for this title | Submit a title for review | Title Index